Feb 20, 2019 Last Updated 3:19 PM, Oct 3, 2017

Alleged Negligence by Government Employee


Sometimes a personal injury plaintiff sues the individual they believe to be liable for their injury, and also the individual's government employer. Under Texas law, the plaintiff may sue both the government employer and the employee, as long as certain requirements are met.

Plaintiff Sues Harris County Corrections and Employee

Paula Trejo alleged that she was injured because an employee of the Harris County Community Supervision and Corrections Department operated a motor vehicle negligently. She sued both the County and the employee. The employee made a motion with the trial court to dismiss Trejo's lawsuit under Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code Ann. § 101.106(f), which provides that if a plaintiff sues a government employee for conduct that is within the scope of the employee's employment, and the lawsuit could have been brought against the employing government unit alone, the suit is considered to be against the employee in his or her official capacity only. If the named employee files a motion to dismiss before the trial court, and the plaintiff fails to dismiss the employee and name the governmental unit within 30 days after the employee files the motion to dismiss, the suit against the employee will be dismissed.

Plaintiff Dismisses Claims and Re-Files

Trejo dismissed her claims against both the employee and the Department, but more than 30 days after the employee's motion. Trejo then re-filed her suit against the Department and the employee for the same claim. The Department moved for summary judgment, asking the trial court to throw out the plaintiff's claims, even though the Department conceded that the employee involved was acting within the scope of his employment. The Department's basis was that Trejo had chosen to sue the employee and failed to substitute the Department as a defendant within Section 101.106(f)'s 30-day time period. The trial court denied the Department's motion, and the Department appealed, basing its appeal on the Texas Tort Claims Act. See Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code Ann. § 101.106. This provision bars a suit against a governmental entity when the plaintiff has sued an employee, unless the governmental unit consents to be sued.

Texas Court of Appeals Affirms Trial Court Ruling for Plaintiff

The Texas Court of Appeals for the Fourteenth District, in Houston, found the Department to be wrong. The Court of Appeals relied on a Texas Supreme Court decision where the Supreme Court held that this portion of subsection (f) did not bar lawsuits like the plaintiff's but merely provided a procedure for an employee sued only in his or her official capacity to be dismissed from a lawsuit. Furthermore, the Court held that subsection (b) also did not apply when the employee was sued only in his official capacity, as long as immunity was otherwise waived under the Texas Tort Claims Act (TTCA). In this case, the Department conceded that the employee was acting in his official capacity when he allegedly contributed to Trejo's injury, and therefore immunity under the TTCA was waived.

The Court of Appeals overruled the Department's only issue on appeal and affirmed the trial court's order denying the Department's motion for summary judgment. The plaintiff's claims against both the employee and the Department were allowed to proceed to trial.

Godsey Martin’s Legal Team is Ready to Serve You

If you have been hit and hurt due to the negligent operation of a motor vehicle by a government employee, you need an attorney who is ready to fight for you.

For an experienced attorney, contact Godsey Martin today. You can call them at 877-IGOTHIT or submit a free case evaluation form online.

Justin Martin

“Early on in my career I worked mainly in service and sales – mostly customer service roles. In doing so, I was naturally in contact with people most of my day. I was able share in the lives of people all over our community. I heard of their struggles to make ends meet, especially when tragedies, illnesses, or accidents impacted them and their families. Many of these good people were unaware of their rights and unable to stand up for themselves. For me, that just didn’t sit right. I knew these folks deserved better. They needed someone who would help them be heard, someone who could provide them the resources to rebuild their lives. I wanted to be the one who stood up on their behalf.”

“I am the proud father of four talented children: Alex, Josh, Sofia, and Ava. My family means the world to me, and is my motivating force each day. I enjoy working out and living a healthy lifestyle.”

Most Read

Find Us on Facebook